Mark Anderson, US CPA & US Expat Tax Help

Moving Abroad Doesn't End Your State Tax Residency — California and New York Can Still Tax You on Worldwide Income.

The federal return is only half the picture. For Americans moving abroad from high-tax states — especially California and New York — state tax residency can persist long after departure unless you take specific, documented steps to break domicile. Mark Anderson, CPA reviews your state residency position, advises on the correct break procedure, and handles all required state filings. 50+ countries served.

🏛️ California FTB Domicile Analysis 🗽 New York Residency Audit Defense 🌍 50+ Countries Served 💼 Fortune 500 Tax Background
13.3%California Top Income Tax Rate — Worldwide Income
10.9%New York Top State Tax Rate
15+Years US Expat Tax Experience
0IRS or State Penalties for Our Clients

You Filed Your Federal Return. But Did California or New York Let You Leave?

Every US citizen living abroad must file a federal Form 1040 reporting worldwide income — that much most expats now know. What catches people off guard is the state layer. Unlike the federal government, which ties taxation to citizenship, states tie taxation to domicile — your permanent legal home. And simply moving to another country does not automatically establish a new domicile or break your old one.

California and New York are the two states most aggressively pursued departing residents. California's Franchise Tax Board (FTB) is widely known for conducting residency audits years after a taxpayer departed, placing the burden of proof on the taxpayer to demonstrate that domicile was truly broken. New York has a separate "statutory residency" trap for expats who keep a New York apartment while living abroad — under which even a non-domiciliary can be taxed as a full resident if they maintain a "permanent place of abode" and spend more than 183 days in the state.

The financial stakes are significant. California taxes residents on worldwide income at rates up to 13.3% — and critically, California does not conform to the federal Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (FEIE). Income excluded on your federal return via Form 2555 can still be fully taxable in California if you remain a California resident for state tax purposes. This is one of the most common and most expensive surprises for expats who moved from California without taking formal steps to break domicile.

Mark Anderson, CPA reviews state residency positions for US expats in 50+ countries — assessing whether domicile was properly broken, advising on corrective steps, and preparing all required state filings. If you moved abroad from California, New York, or any other income-tax state, your state residency position deserves the same attention as your federal return.

California does not recognize the FEIE. If you remain a California resident for state tax purposes — because domicile was not properly broken — your foreign-earned income excluded from your federal return via Form 2555 is still subject to California income tax. On $120,000 of foreign income, California tax at the applicable rate can exceed $10,000 — owed every year for as long as California considers you a resident.

Is Your State Residency at Risk?

Review these questions. If any apply, your state tax residency position should be formally reviewed before your next filing season.

  • You moved abroad from California, New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts, or Virginia
  • You still own a home in your prior state (even if rented out)
  • You kept a bank account, car registration, or driver's license in your prior state after moving
  • Your spouse or children remained in your prior state after you moved abroad
  • You have not filed a part-year resident state return for the year you moved
  • You have not formally established domicile in a new state or abroad
  • You returned to your prior state for more than a few weeks in any year since departing
  • You receive California-source income (RSUs, rental, business) while living abroad

State Tax Risk for US Expats — From Critical to None

Not all states are equal. Your state of prior residency determines how aggressively you need to plan your departure. Here is a practical risk view of the states expats most commonly move from.

🔴 Critical Risk

California

The most aggressive state for residency audits. The FTB places the burden of proof on the departing taxpayer, actively uses 19+ domicile factors, and does not recognize the FEIE. Residency audits can go back 4 years (or indefinitely if no return was filed).

Top rate: 13.3% — on worldwide income
🔴 Critical Risk

New York

Two separate residency traps: domicile AND statutory residency (183+ days + permanent place of abode). Keeping a New York apartment while abroad can trigger full NY tax even if you're domiciled elsewhere. NYC tax adds another layer.

Top rate: 10.9% state + 3.876% NYC
🟡 High Risk

New Jersey

Aggressive residency enforcement, statutory residency rules similar to New York. Departure must be documented. Income earned from NJ sources continues to be taxable even as a non-resident.

Top rate: 10.75% on worldwide income
🟡 High Risk

Massachusetts

Active residency audits for high-income departures. Stock option and deferred compensation income sourced to Massachusetts can create filing obligations even for non-residents after departure.

Flat rate: 5% on most income
🟡 Moderate Risk

Virginia & Illinois

Both enforce residency rules and tax worldwide income of residents. Less aggressive than CA/NY in pursuing departing residents, but departure must still be documented and part-year returns filed correctly.

VA: 5.75% · IL: 4.95% flat
🟢 No State Tax

TX · FL · NV · WY · WA · SD · AK

No state income tax — no state residency risk for expats. Many Americans moving abroad from high-tax states first establish domicile in one of these states before departing, eliminating state tax exposure entirely.

State income tax rate: 0%

Strategy note: If you lived in a no-income-tax state before moving abroad, state residency is a non-issue. If you lived in California or New York, it is potentially the largest tax problem you have — and one that most generic expat tax services do not adequately address.

California vs. New York: How Each State Determines If You're Still a Resident

The rules differ. Understanding exactly what each state looks for is the first step in planning a defensible departure — or defending a prior one.

🏛️ California

Franchise Tax Board (FTB) — Domicile-Based

The core test: California taxes you if California is your domicile — your permanent home, the place you intend to return to when away. You can only have one domicile at a time.

The FTB's 19 domicile factors include: location of your principal residence; location of your spouse and children; location of your employment and professional licenses; location of your vehicles; where you bank; where you are registered to vote; where you hold club memberships and have social ties; where you keep personal property of sentimental or significant value.

The burden of proof is on you. If the FTB believes you were a California domiciliary, they will audit and demand documentation proving you established a new domicile elsewhere. Vague claims of "moving abroad" are not sufficient.

The FEIE trap: California does not conform to the federal FEIE (Form 2555). If you remain a California resident, all foreign-earned income excluded on your federal return remains fully taxable by California — at rates up to 13.3%.

What you must do before leaving: Change your driver's license, re-register vehicles, close California bank accounts, update your address everywhere, cancel voter registration, and — critically — not maintain a California home as a personal residence available for your use.

🗽 New York

NY Dept. of Taxation — Domicile AND Statutory Residency

Two separate tests — either can make you a New York taxpayer:

Test 1 — Domicile: Same concept as California — your permanent home. If New York is your domicile, you owe NY tax on worldwide income regardless of where you live or how long you stay abroad.

Test 2 — Statutory Residency (the expat trap): Even if you are NOT domiciled in New York, you are treated as a New York resident for tax purposes if you: (a) maintain a "permanent place of abode" in New York AND (b) spend more than 183 days in New York during the tax year.

What is a "permanent place of abode"? Any dwelling you maintain and have access to — including an apartment rented in your name, a parent's home where you keep a room, or a home you own. The apartment does not need to be your primary home. It needs to be available for your use.

The days trap: Days in New York are counted any time you are physically present in New York for any portion of the day — including transit days. 183 days is approximately 6 months. Expats who return to New York for extended visits and maintain a New York apartment must track days very carefully.

NYC tax: New York City levies an additional income tax (up to 3.876%) on top of state tax for days resident in NYC. This applies under the same residency rules.

The Domicile Break Checklist — What You Must Do Before Leaving a High-Tax State

A successful domicile break requires affirmative action — not just physical departure. These are the concrete steps that, when completed and documented, establish that you have genuinely abandoned your prior state domicile. Every step should be completed before or immediately upon moving abroad, and the date of each action should be documented.

✅ Actions That Break Domicile

  • Obtain a foreign driver's license and surrender your state license (or obtain license in your new domicile state)
  • Re-register all vehicles outside your prior state
  • Cancel voter registration in your prior state
  • Close bank accounts in your prior state and open new accounts abroad or in your new domicile state
  • Update your primary address with the IRS, all financial institutions, and all professional contacts to your foreign address
  • Cancel state-issued professional licenses if no longer needed for work
  • Remove personal property of sentimental or significant value from the state
  • Resign from local clubs, organizations, and memberships tied to your prior state
  • File a part-year resident state return in the year of departure, establishing the departure date on record
  • If your spouse and children remain in the state, document clearly that this is not your permanent home
  • Establish genuine ties to your new location — lease abroad, foreign bank account, foreign ID

❌ What Does NOT Break Domicile

  • Simply moving to another country without severing state ties
  • Keeping a home in the state "just in case" or for family use
  • Maintaining a California or New York driver's license
  • Keeping vehicles registered in the state
  • Remaining registered to vote in your prior state
  • Using your prior state address for IRS correspondence
  • Spending summers or extended periods back in your prior state
  • Having your spouse or children remain in the state with no documented plan to join you abroad
Illustrative Example

What goes wrong: Sarah moves from San Francisco to Singapore in March. She sublets her apartment to a friend, keeps her California driver's license, leaves her car registered in California, doesn't update her bank accounts, and doesn't file a California part-year return. Two years later, the California FTB sends a residency questionnaire. Because Sarah's California ties were never severed, the FTB asserts she remained a California domiciliary — and proposes tax, interest, and penalties on two years of Singapore income at California rates up to 13.3%. The FEIE exclusions on her federal return provide no protection.

What should have happened: Before departing, Sarah should have surrendered her CA license, re-registered her vehicle out of state (or sold it), updated all financial accounts and correspondence addresses, filed a 2023 part-year resident California return establishing her departure date, and obtained a Singapore driver's license and opened a Singapore bank account — all documented with dated records.

Illustrative example. Sarah is not a real client.

Complete State Tax Residency Service — From Analysis to Filing

Mark Anderson, CPA handles state residency analysis and compliance as part of the broader expat tax engagement — because getting the federal return right while ignoring the state layer leaves a significant and unnecessary tax risk open. See full pricing at our rates page.

🔍

State Residency Position Analysis

Mark reviews your prior state of residence, when and how you moved abroad, what ties you maintained or severed, and whether a defensible domicile break occurred. He identifies the risk exposure and advises on what steps remain to be taken — or what corrective action is needed if domicile was not properly broken.

📋

Part-Year Resident State Returns

In the year you move abroad, you file a part-year resident return covering the period of state residency and a federal return for the full year. Mark prepares the part-year return — establishing the departure date on official record, computing state tax correctly on the resident-period income, and ensuring the state filing does not inadvertently extend residency beyond the intended departure date.

📊

Non-Resident State Returns (Ongoing)

After departure, California-source or New York-source income remains taxable by those states regardless of where you live. Rental income from California property, stock options sourced to California employment, or business income from California clients all require ongoing California non-resident filings. Mark handles these alongside your annual federal return.

🏠

Property and Home Guidance

What to do with a California or New York home before moving abroad is one of the most consequential decisions for state residency. Mark advises on the options — sale, arm's-length rental, or maintaining it — and explains the state residency implications of each. He coordinates with your real estate and legal advisors where applicable.

📍

New Domicile Strategy

For expats departing from high-tax states, establishing domicile in a no-income-tax state before moving abroad is a legitimate and widely used strategy. Mark advises on which state makes sense, what genuine domicile establishment requires, and how to document it — so the no-tax-state domicile can be defended if the prior state audits.

⚖️

FTB and NY Tax Dept. Correspondence

If the California FTB or New York Department of Taxation has sent a residency questionnaire, audit notice, or proposed assessment, Mark handles the response — preparing the written response, assembling documentation of the domicile break, and managing all correspondence with the state tax authority. See also our penalty abatement page if penalties have been assessed.

Why State Residency Requires a Specialist — Not a Generic Expat Tax Service

Most expat tax services focus exclusively on the federal return. State residency is treated as an afterthought, left to the client to sort out, or simply ignored. This is one of the most significant gaps in the expat tax service market.

Service AreaMark Anderson CPAGeneric Expat Tax ServicesDIY / TurboTax
California FTB domicile analysis✓ IncludedRarely covered✗
New York statutory residency (183 days + PPA rule)✓ ReviewedOften missed✗
FEIE / California non-conformity explained✓ Always flaggedRarely explained✗
Part-year resident state returns prepared✓ YesAdd-on, if at allBasic support only
No-tax-state domicile strategy advised✓ Pre-departure planning✗ Not typically✗
California-source income (RSUs, rental) — non-resident filings✓ HandledInconsistent✗
FTB residency questionnaire response prepared✓ Included✗ Referral needed✗
100% remote — no US visit required✓ AlwaysVaries✓

⚠️ A note on legal vs. tax advice: State domicile disputes that escalate to formal audits or litigation may require a state tax attorney in addition to a CPA. Mark handles the tax preparation and compliance side — FTB questionnaires, state return preparation, and strategy advice. For formal administrative appeals or litigation, he coordinates with state tax counsel. He will tell you clearly at intake if your situation has progressed beyond CPA-level advisory.

State Tax Residency — Flat-Fee Pricing

State residency services are quoted as flat fees after the free consultation, where Mark determines the scope of work required. Pricing depends on prior state, number of years involved, whether a part-year return is needed, and whether ongoing non-resident filings are required. Full details at our rates page.

State Residency Analysis
From $300

Review of your prior state residency position, domicile break assessment, and written guidance on outstanding risks and recommended corrective steps. No filings included — analysis only.

Part-Year Resident Return
From $400

Preparation of a part-year resident state return (California Form 540NR, New York IT-203, or other state) for the year of departure. Includes state residency analysis.

Always Included
  • Free 30-minute initial consultation
  • State-specific domicile analysis
  • California FTB / NY Tax Dept. risk assessment
  • FEIE / state non-conformity review
  • Pre-departure domicile break checklist
  • Year-round advisory support

From State Residency Review to Full Compliance — The Process

Mark handles state residency reviews and filings 100% remotely. You do not need to be in the US to discuss, plan, or resolve your state tax position. For expats who also have federal compliance questions, Mark's Streamlined Filing Procedure service addresses federal non-compliance alongside the state layer — often as part of the same engagement.

1

Free 30-Minute Residency Consultation

Tell Mark your prior state of residence, when you moved abroad, what ties you maintained, and whether you have received any correspondence from your state's tax authority. He will identify the risk level, explain what domicile-break steps were or were not completed, and advise on the immediate priority — whether that is filing a belated part-year return, responding to a state notice, or simply documenting existing steps correctly.

2

Domicile Break Assessment

Mark reviews your specific facts — the timing of your departure, what actions were taken, what ties remain, your property situation, spouse and family location, and any state-source income. He produces a written assessment of whether a defensible domicile break occurred, what the residual risk is, and what corrective steps (if any) can still be taken to strengthen the position.

3

State Returns Prepared and Filed

Where part-year or non-resident state returns are required, Mark prepares and reviews them — establishing the departure date on record for the year-of-departure return, and correctly sourcing and reporting any ongoing state-source income (RSUs, rental, business income) for subsequent non-resident years. You review and sign before submission.

4

Documentation Package

If your domicile break needs to be documented for a potential FTB or New York audit, Mark advises on what records to gather and maintain — dated evidence of the specific domicile-break actions taken. Having this documentation organized and accessible significantly reduces the cost and stress of responding to a residency questionnaire if one arrives later.

5

Annual Review & Ongoing Compliance

State residency is not a one-time question — it needs to be reviewed each year in light of how many days you spent in your prior state, whether any state-source income was earned, and whether any circumstances changed that could revive the prior state's residency claim. Mark includes this review in your annual federal and state compliance package. If you also need pre-departure planning, see our US expat tax service page for the full annual filing engagement.

State Tax Residency Questions — What Expats Ask Most Often

Straightforward answers to the state tax residency questions Mark hears most from US expats — especially those who moved from California or New York.

No — and this is the most important thing to understand. Moving abroad does not automatically terminate state tax residency. You must affirmatively establish a new domicile outside the state by severing the ties the state uses to claim residency — driver's license, vehicle registration, bank accounts, voter registration, property — and establishing new ties elsewhere. California and New York are the most aggressive states in pursuing this question. Simply living abroad for months or years without taking these formal steps leaves your prior state's claim intact.

Domicile is your permanent legal home — the place you intend to remain indefinitely or return to when away. You can only have one domicile at a time. For state tax purposes, your domicile state taxes your worldwide income, regardless of where you physically live. If California remains your domicile after you move to Singapore, California taxes you on Singapore income at up to 13.3% — on top of whatever Singapore levies. Breaking domicile requires establishing a new permanent home somewhere else and abandoning the intention to return to your prior state. It is a facts-and-circumstances test, not a bright line.

The California Franchise Tax Board (FTB) uses a multi-factor domicile test that examines 19+ factors: where you maintain your primary home; where your spouse and children are; where you work and maintain professional licenses; where your vehicles are registered; where you bank; where you are registered to vote; where you hold club memberships and maintain social ties; where you keep valuables and personal property; and where you spend the most time. The FTB places the burden of proof on the taxpayer — you must demonstrate, with documentation, that you have established a new domicile elsewhere and abandoned California as your permanent home. The FTB can audit residency going back 4 years (or indefinitely if no return was filed for the disputed year).

Yes — if California still considers you a domiciliary or resident, it taxes your worldwide income, including your foreign salary, foreign business income, and foreign investment income. The critical additional point: California does not conform to the federal Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (FEIE, Form 2555). Income you excluded from your federal return using Form 2555 is still subject to California income tax if you remain a California resident. At California's top rate of 13.3%, this can mean $10,000–$15,000 in annual California tax on income that generated zero federal income tax. This is one of the most financially significant state tax issues for expats who moved from California.

New York's statutory residency rule taxes you as a full New York resident — even if you are NOT domiciled in New York — if you meet both conditions: (1) you maintain a "permanent place of abode" in New York, and (2) you spend more than 183 days in New York during the tax year. A permanent place of abode is any dwelling you maintain and have access to, including an apartment rented in your name, a room in a family home, or any property available for your personal use. The danger for expats: if you keep a New York apartment (even renting it to others when you are abroad) and spend more than 183 days in New York during any year, New York treats you as a full resident for that year — taxing your worldwide income. Days in New York are counted for any portion of a day you are physically present in the state.

Potentially yes — depending on how the property is held and used. In California, maintaining a home that is "available for your personal use" is one of the strongest indicators of continuing domicile — even if you rent it out, if the arrangement is not truly arm's-length (e.g., renting to a family member at below-market rate, or retaining the right to stay there when you visit), the FTB can treat it as your California home. In New York, keeping an apartment or home that is available for your use constitutes a "permanent place of abode" — which, combined with 183+ days in New York, triggers statutory residency. The safest path: sell the property before establishing your new domicile abroad, or rent it at full arm's length on the open market with no personal use rights.

For expats moving from California, New York, or other high-tax states, establishing domicile in a no-income-tax state (Texas, Florida, Nevada, Wyoming, Washington, South Dakota, or Alaska) before moving abroad is a legitimate strategy used by many Americans who move overseas. If done correctly, it breaks the high-tax state's claim and replaces it with a state that has zero income tax — meaning your foreign income has no state tax exposure at all. "Correctly" means genuinely establishing domicile: obtaining a driver's license, registering a vehicle, having a real residential address (not just a P.O. box), spending meaningful time there, and updating your address everywhere. Mark advises on this strategy as part of pre-departure planning. It requires real steps — not just paperwork — but for high earners moving from California or New York, the annual tax savings can be substantial.

In the year you move abroad, you file a part-year resident state return for your prior state. For California, this is Form 540NR (California Nonresident or Part-Year Resident Income Tax Return). For New York, it is IT-203 (Nonresident and Part-Year Resident Income Tax Return). The part-year return reports income earned through the date of departure as taxable by the state, and income earned after departure as non-taxable (unless it is state-source income from the prior state). Filing this return promptly — and accurately documenting the departure date — is important for establishing the official record of when residency ended. Failing to file a part-year return in the year of departure is a red flag that states interpret as continuing residency.

Yes — California sources RSU income based on where you performed services during the vesting period, not where you live when the shares vest. If you performed work in California during the period between the RSU grant date and the vesting date, the portion of the RSU income attributable to California workdays is taxable by California — even after you have moved abroad and successfully broken California domicile. This is called California's "source-based" RSU taxation, and it can continue generating California tax obligations for years after departure. Mark prepares California non-resident returns (Form 540NR) to report and pay tax on this California-source RSU income, while correctly excluding non-California-source income.

California's standard statute of limitations for residency audits is 4 years from the later of the return due date or the date filed. However — and this is important — if no California return was filed for a given year (because you believed you were no longer a California resident), the statute of limitations never starts running. California can audit indefinitely for years with no return on file. This means an expat who moved abroad in 2019 and filed no California return after that year can face a California residency audit in 2025 or 2026 covering all years since departure. Proactively filing a part-year return in the year of departure — and filing non-resident returns for California-source income in subsequent years — starts the clock running on the statute of limitations and demonstrates ongoing good-faith compliance.

Possibly — this is one of the most significant domicile factors in California's analysis. Where your spouse and children live is a major indicator of where your "closest connections" are, which is central to California's domicile determination. If your spouse and children remain in California with no documented plan to join you abroad, and you return to California regularly to be with them, the FTB will likely assert that California is still your domicile. This does not mean it is impossible to break California domicile when a spouse remains in California — but it is significantly harder and requires strong documentation showing that your permanent home and primary ties are genuinely elsewhere. Mark evaluates the specific facts of these situations during the free consultation.

A California FTB residency questionnaire (FTB Form 4600 or similar) is a formal information request that initiates a residency audit. You are required to respond — ignoring it results in the FTB proceeding with a proposed tax assessment. The questionnaire asks for detailed information about your living arrangements, ties to California, days spent in California, and out-of-state ties. Mark prepares the written response — explaining your domicile break, providing documentation of the steps taken, and presenting your facts in the most favorable and legally accurate way. A well-organized, well-documented response at the questionnaire stage typically resolves most California residency audits without escalation to a formal examination. Contacting Mark as soon as the questionnaire arrives — not after the deadline — is critical.

If You Moved Abroad From California or New York Without a Formal Domicile Break — You May Still Owe State Tax. Let's Find Out.

Mark Anderson, CPA reviews state residency positions for US expats in 50+ countries. Free 30-minute consultation. No obligation. If there is a risk, he will tell you — and if there are steps you can still take to address it, he will tell you those too.

Schedule Your Free State Residency Consultation

Tell Mark your prior state of residence, when you moved abroad, what ties you maintained or severed, and whether you have received any state tax correspondence. He reviews your position and advises on the risk and recommended next steps — all in a free 30-minute consultation.

  • Free 30-minute state residency review
  • California FTB and New York domicile analysis
  • Part-year and non-resident state returns prepared
  • Pre-departure domicile break strategy and documentation
  • FTB questionnaire and state audit responses handled
  • 100% online — US expat CPA serving 50+ countries worldwide

Prefer to reach us directly?

📞 +1 (646) 961-1866 💬 WhatsApp ✉ mark@markandersoncpa.com Line ID: marquenyc

    Your Name (required)

    Your Email (required)

    Phone Number (required)

    Line ID

    Additional Details (required)